Search This Blog

Thursday, May 13, 2010

How to read John

Have you ever heard someone tell a new believer that they should start reading the book of John first?

Why does anyone say that? Of all four of the Good News books, John is by far the most complex book to comprehend.

First, as one read this, don't automatically assume that this goes with Matthew, Mark, or Luke. John is completely a different point of view. I'm not sure how else to say this. There is a lot of mystery in John that when you really try to understand what he is saying, you really don't get it. Don't try to understand everything at once. It is very important not to draw absolute conclusions, but simply ask questions, and realize that once you believe that you have an answer figured out, it really only leads to more questions.

For example, why does John begin with discussion "the Word." In Greek, this is the term "Logos," which carries a multiplicity of connotations. In Hebrew, the term would be translated as "Devarim," which is the Hebrew word for "Deuteronomy." So, now we can only begin to ask the question, "What does 'the Word' mean? Are we talking about "the law," or "the Torah?" Are we talking about Yeshua? Are they the same? How? Why? It's fun to read all of the different commentary on John 1. People's creativity on this chapter is out of this world. Google it. See for yourself.

Only one other piece of information I think is most relevant to understanding John. Everything in John connects to a Jewish festival. When you are reading, look for the clue words:

In John 1, there is an understanding that this is a Rosh HaShanah passage, because the language is a reference to Genesis 1:1. The creation account was the beginning of everything, thus the terms "in the beginning" used in both books. In addition, the reference to "Light" in John 1:4 and Genesis 1:3 have a connection.

In John 2, we see that there is a wedding, but then the text immediately jumps into Passover. John 2:13.

In John 3, we see that Nicodemus "came by night." There is a discussion about "born again" and "Light." Both of these concepts are Rosh Chodesh (New Moon) terms, especially the "born again" phrase. Each new month, the moon is "born again." This Rosh Chodesh could either be the one BEFORE Passover (Nissan) or the one AFTER Passover (Iyar).

From John 4, we could understand that this took place during the Counting of the Omer, because in John 5, we understand that it is "a feast," most likely Shavuot, but perhaps Sukkot.

John 6:4, it was the Passover again.

John 7:2, it was the "feast of booths," or "tabernacles," or Sukkot. This seems to be the context through chapter 9.

In John 10:22, we learn that this chapter takes place at the Feast of Dedication (Chunnukah).

In John 12:1, we read that it was Passover. Since both chapter 11-12 deal with Lazarus, it is safe to assume chapter 11 was a Passover passage, and not a Chanukah passage.

The whole rest of the book is Passover, unleavened bread, and Firstfruits.

Only chapter 21 may be difficult to place. We know it is during the Counting of the Omer, prior to Yeshua's ascension on the 40th day of the Count.

    Therefore, as you read John, see if you can make connections to the feast on which He is discussing something.

Wednesday, May 5, 2010

Good Slavery and the Jubilee?

Leviticus 25:47-55 "If a stranger or sojourner with you becomes rich, and your brother beside him becomes poor and sells himself to the stranger or sojourner with you or to a member of the stranger's clan, 48 then after he is sold he may be redeemed. One of his brothers may redeem him, 49 or his uncle or his cousin may redeem him, or a close relative from his clan may redeem him. Or if he grows rich he may redeem himself. 50 He shall calculate with his buyer from the year when he sold himself to him until the year of jubilee, and the price of his sale shall vary with the number of years. The time he was with his owner shall be rated as the time of a hired servant. 51 If there are still many years left, he shall pay proportionately for his redemption some of his sale price. 52 If there remain but a few years until the year of jubilee, he shall calculate and pay for his redemption in proportion to his years of service. 53 He shall treat him as a servant hired year by year. He shall not rule ruthlessly over him in your sight. 54 And if he is not redeemed by these means, then he and his children with him shall be released in the year of jubilee. 55 For it is to me that the people of Israel are servants. They are my servants whom I brought out of the land of Egypt: I am the LORD your God.

The laws of slavery in Scripture are nothing like the kinds of slavery that we have heard about in the American past or in modern Africa today. Today, slavery is in all cases, a very grave concern for all of us to consider. It cannot be tolerated.

Thus, when we come to this passage in Leviticus, one must be a little curious as to why slavery was sanctioned in Scripture. In all of its cases, slavery was a result of becoming poor. One can only imagine what kinds of situations caused this terrible bankruptcy to overcome this man and/or his family. Perhaps his crops failed for a number of years. Perhaps he made a poor trading decision. One can imagine. In Leviticus 25, there is a thorough discussion of the Jubilee year (hayovel). In the Jubilee year, property is redeemed. In other words, if a family plot of land was sold, either to a fellow Israelite or a stranger in the land, the plot was returned to the family of inheritance. Thus, each Israelite was guaranteed his perpetual inheritance, in theory, forever. (Obviously, the commandments about whose inheritance land belong to which Israelites today is impossible to determine.) The purpose goes beyond just a financial means of protection; it also is a means for families to reconcile, for the families to come back like some sort of a year of family reunion. However, not only is the land redeemed, but so are the Israelites who have become slaves.

This chapter is very explicit about how Israelites were to treat fellow Israelites. Lev. 25:39 explicitly states that a fellow countryman is to be treated not as a slave, but as a "hired servant" (v. 40). Even so, in the year of Jubilee, his property is returned to him and he is reunited with his whole family. The purpose of this temporary "slavery" is to illustrate redemption. That redemption could be brought about by a kinsman redeemer (v. 49). On one hand, this illustration serves as a word-picture of what Messiah would one day do for all of mankind. On the other hand, the more practical application, both for the Israelites and us today, is that G-d puts the responsibility of helping the poor, especially the poor relatives, onto one's family. There is no welfare system, no clothes closet, no food pantry. Not only that, but poverty was only temporary, for in the normal life span of every person, there would be at least one jubilee year. G-d purposefully built into the Torah, "the do-over" button.

However, there is a particular case that required a very particular resolution: What would happen if an Israelite had become the legitimate slave of a stranger in the land (ger). Consider the implications of what this means. In the Artscroll Chumash, Sforno consider this situation to be very bad indeed. It is assumed that the ger is automatically considered an idolater. Yet, in other places, the ger is translated to mean "a proselyte." (Tim Hegg does a very good job explaining why associating ger with "proselyte" is achronistic, meaning the term and concept of full proselyte, a Greek word, is a 2nd-3rd century CE rabbinic concept, and not used in this way in the Torah nor the 1st Century CE. See "articles" at www.torahresource.com .) The point here is that a "stranger-in-the-land" living in Israel would not necessarily be a pagan, as is presupposed. In fact, it is unlikely that this is the case at all, since the Torah binds the non-Israelite to also treat the Israelite as a "hired servant" (v 53). Furthermore, the other Israelites are to pay attention to make sure that the Israelite is "not treated with severity (v 53). Finally, the stranger-in-the-land is obligated to release the Israelite at the year of Jubilee. Based upon these statements, it is more likely that the "stranger-in-the-land" abides by Torah and is included amongst those in the land.

There is a greater significance here that can be alluded to by Paul and James in the New Testament. Romans 1:1, "Paul, a bondservant of Messiah Yeshua…" In Phillipians 1:1, "Paul and Timothy, bond-servants of Messiah Yeshua…" And finally, James 1:1, "James, a bond-servant of G-d and of the L-rd, Yeshua Messiah…" Is it possible that Paul and James understood their status as slaves to Messiah in the context of a slave, but only until a type of "Jubilee year" which would then set them free? Yeshua says something about being a servant/slave in Matthew 20:26-28 "It shall not be so among you. But whoever would be great among you must be your servant, and whoever would be first among you must be your slave, even as the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many." Later, Paul says, 1 Corinthians 7:21-22 "Were you a slave when called? Do not be concerned about it. (But if you can gain your freedom, avail yourself of the opportunity.) For he who was called in the Lord as a slave is a freedman of the Lord. Likewise he who was free when called is a slave of Christ." Of course, in the first century context, the Roman style slavery is not to be confused with the Torah-style slavery. There was no Jubilee in the Roman context. Yet, in all of these cases, there seems to be a promise of release. While it may seem to be oxymoronic, slavery to Yeshua the Messiah is actually freedom.

Now consider a mind-set today. Though many of us consider ourselves "free," we are in fact more slaves today than in many other times in history. People are enslaved to jobs, to credit cards, to bad family situations, to drugs, to alcohol, to the internet, to playing games, to their cars, to the government social programs, and on and on that list can go. Yet, what if we were to leave all of that alone and become bond-servants of Yeshua only? What would that look like today? What is certain is that one day, there is a final Jubilee, a year of release. Even though Paul, Timothy, and James considered themselves bond-servants to Messiah, it seems implied that they knew their service was temporary. In 2 Timothy, Paul refers to having "fought the fight, having finished the race, and having kept the faith." Our prayer should be similar. Let us endure until the end. Meanwhile, let us put ourselves in the position of a slave, for Yeshua and for each other. What better way to show our love for one another than through being one another's servants.

Monday, May 3, 2010

An Eye for an Eye and Loving Your Neighbor as Yourself: An Example of Properly Interpreting the Torah

Emor - אמור : "Say"
Torah : Leviticus 21:1-24:23
Haftarah : Ezekiel 44:15-31
Gospel : Luke 18-20

In this week's Torah Portion we come across one if the most misinterpreted passages of Scripture. Read Leviticus 24:17-22: 17 "Whoever takes a human life shall surely be put to death. 18 Whoever takes an animal's life shall make it good, life for life. 19 If anyone injures his neighbor, as he has done it shall be done to him, 20 fracture for fracture, eye for eye, tooth for tooth; whatever injury he has given a person shall be given to him. 21 Whoever kills an animal shall make it good, and whoever kills a person shall be put to death. 22 You shall have the same rule for the sojourner and for the native, for I am the LORD your God."

The most common interpretation of this verse is that if you do something against another person, that something must be "paid back" against you. Other topic words that are use to describe this section are "retribution" or "vengeance."

This section of scriptures is sometimes classified in Christian commentaries as "civil law," as opposed to "ceremonial law" or "moral law." In other words, these are a set of laws that governed how the Israelites were to live during that time. These "civil laws" do not apply to anyone today. Those who subdivide the Scripture in this way will have difficulty figuring out how classify laws under these three headings since no place in Scripture uses any of these terms. Furthermore, there is no Jewish classification system such as this. These three terms were developed primarily around the time of the Reformation, and as such, they are one of many ways by which someone can end up in "replacement theology," whereby the "Law" to the Old Testament are bad and "done away with", and "Grace" and the New Testament and viewed as good and right. As a result of applying replacement theological approaches to this passage of Leviticus, many within the Christian spheres either avoid reading such passages. These "civil laws" are "done away with" because of Jesus gave us a "new covenant" and "new commandments." Once this line of reasoning takes hold within a Christian community, there have been historical instances in which Christian peoople are abused by politically power-hungry Christian theologians and leaders. One can remember how priests and lords of feudalism would abuse their peasants by literally applying Scriptures such as Leviticus 24 in this way. Thus, during that Age, one could imagine people convicted of crimes walking around without appendages and eyes. Throughout Christian history, the Bible has been applied without recognition of the cultural context in which the Bible was written. In other words, the historical/grammatical approach of the Scriptures has been forgotten or neglected. Without making connections to the Jewish understanding of specific Scriptures, the meaning of these verses is negated and any application of the verse would be out of context.

A selection taken from www.grafted-in.com seems to explain very well the Jewish discussion:

That the sages of antiquity had differing opinions as to the meanings behind

these verses [Lev. 24:17-22] is made evident from our Talmudic extract, taken from Tractate

Bava Kama:


 

MISHNA: One who wounds his neighbor is liable to pay the following five things, viz.: damage, pain, healing, loss of time, and disgrace. "Damage."--If he blinds one's eye, cuts off his hand, or breaks his leg, the injured person is considered as if he were a slave sold in the market, and he is appraised at his former and his present value. "Pain."--If he burns him with a spit or with a nail, if even only on the nail (of his hand or foot), where it produces no wound, it is appraised how much a man his equal would take to suffer such pain. "Healing."--If he caused him bodily injury,he must heal him; if pus collected by reason of the wound, he must cause him to be healed; if, however, not by reason of the wound, he is free. If the wound heals up and breaks out again, even several times, he must cause it to be healed; if, however, it once heals up thoroughly, he is no more obliged to heal it. "Loss of time."--The injured person is considered as if be were a watchman of a pumpkin field, as he was already paid the value of his hand or foot. The disgrace is appraised with consideration of the station and rank of the one who causes as well as of the one who suffers it.


 

GEMARA: Why so? Perhaps it is to be taken literally, for the Scripture reads [Ex. xxi. 24]: "Eye for eye"? This cannot enter the mind, as we have learned in the following Boraitha: Lest one say, if he blinds one's eye or cuts off one's hand, that the same should be done unto him, therefore it is

written [Lev. xxiv. 21]: "And he that killeth a beast shall make restitution for it; and he that killeth a man," etc. As in case of a beast only the value is paid, so also in case of a man. And lest one say, Does not the Scripture read [Numb. xxxv. 31]: "Moreover, ye shall take no redemption for the person of a murderer, who is guilty of death"? you may say that from this, very verse it may be inferred that no redemption money is to be taken for a murderer, but redemption money is to be taken for one who destroys such members of the body as cannot grow on again. We have learned in a Boraitha: R. Simeon b. Johi said: "Eye for eye" means its value. You say, its value. Perhaps it means literally? Nay, for what should be done when a blind man blinds another, etc.--how should be fulfilled the commandment "eye for eye"? And lest one say that such a

case is an exception, therefore the Scripture reads [Lev. xxiv. 22]: "One manner of judicial law shall ye have"; from which is to be inferred that it means a law which can be applied alike to all human cases. In the school of R. Ishmael it was taught: The Scripture reads [ibid., ibid.

20]: "So should it be given unto him"; and by "given" is meant a thing which is given from hand to hand. If so, how are the preceding words in the same verse to be explained? "In the manner he should give a bodily defect," etc. (hence the word "give" is used also for such a thing as is not given from hand to hand)? It may be explained thus: The school of R. Ishmael deduce it from a superfluous verse, thus: Let us see. It reads already in the preceding verse [ibid. 19]: "And if a man cause a bodily defect in his neighbor; as he hath done, so shall it be done unto him."

Why, then, the repetition in verse 20? To indicate that it means money. But still the above-stated objection as to the use of the word "give" in the beginning of the verse remains? Because at the end of the verse the Scripture desired to use a term from which it should be deduced that it

means money. It used the same expression also here. The school of R. Hyya deduce it from the following: The Scripture reads [Deut. xix. 21]: "Hand for hand" --that means something that can be passed from hand to hand, i.e., money.3 Well-respected Torah scholar Nechama Leibowitz adds her comments on how the Chazal (ancient sages) wrestled with the intended meaning behind this Levitical passage, eventually favoring a monetary interpretation: Few are the verses from the Bible which have been so frequently and widely misunderstood by Jew and non-Jew as verse 24:20, from which our title is taken. This misconception has transformed our text into a symbol, the embodiment of vengeance at its cruelest level. One who wishes to express his opposition to forgiveness, concession, and compensation, insisting instead on his pound of flesh, on retaliation of the most brutal and painful kind, resorts to the phrase: "Eye for eye," a formula which conjures up a vision of hacked limbs and gouged eyes. Even he who is familiar with the traditional Rabbinical interpretation of our text, "eye for eye," i.e., monetary compensation, does not rule out the possibility of this being merely an apologetical explanation, a later toning down of ancient barbarity, humanization of the severity of the Torah by subsequent generations. But this is not the case. On the contrary, our Sages and commentators adduce many and varied proofs indicating that the plain sense of the text can be no other than monetary compensation.


 

By contrast, the Karaite attacked the Rabbinic interpretation on two counts, first from the wording of the text. The Gaon demonstrated that the two phrases do not necessarily bear out the Karaite interpretation. (Benno Jacob notes that the case of Adoni-Bezek – As I have done, so God has requited me (Judges 1:7) is no proof to the contrary, for there he uses a different verb in each clause of the phrase, and is therefore not comparable to our verse). The proof from Samson is the clearest indication that the phraseology when… implies an equivalent or analogous, but not identical punishment. Again, from Bava Kama: "Eye for eye": Rav Saadya said we cannot take this text literally. For if a man deprived his fellow of a third of his normal eyesight by his blow, how can the retaliatory blow be so calculated as to have the same results, neither more nor less, nor blinding him completely? Such an exact reproduction of the effects is even more difficult in the case of a wound or bruise which, if in a dangerous spot, might result in death. The very idea cannot be tolerated. Ben Zuta (a Karaite) retorted: But surely it is explicitly written: (Lev. 24:20) As he has maimed a man so shall it be rendered to him. The Gaon answered: The word on, implying so shall punishment be imposed upon him. Ben Zuta retorted: As he did, so shall be done to him! The Gaon replied: We have in the case of Samson (Judges 15:11): As they did to me, so I did to them, and Samson did not take their wives and give them to others (as they had done to him), but only punished them. Ben Zuta retorted: What if the attacker was a poor man, what would be his punishment? The Gaon replied: What if a blind man blinded one with normal eyesight, what should be done to him? The poor man can become rich and pay; only the blind man can never pay for what he did! The Karaite then forsook the argument from the wording of the text and attacked the Rabbinical interpretation from the point of view of feasibility of its implementation. Here Ben Zuta evidently did not realize that by doing so he was advancing the objection that could be raised against all judicial fines. Just as he asked: What if the attacker is a poor man, so he could have asked: What if any defendant on whom a fine was imposed was a poor man? He thus played into R. Saadya's hands by showing him that the same flaw in execution that could be pointed out in the monetary interpretation could be objected in the literal one, bringing in R. Shimon b. Yohai's argument.


 

Conclusions

First a quote from my own commentary to Parashat Mishpatim: [Exodus] Chapter 21 – Verses 22-27 speak about restitution in the event of accidental injury. We are familiar with the saying, "An eye for an eye; a tooth for a tooth." We remember that our LORD Yeshua made a comment

about this in the B'rit Chadashah book of Mattityahu 5:38-42. We often feel that his comments reflect the right, enacted by this particular Torah passage, to go out and take "revenge" on the individual who took our "eye" or "tooth." In Yeshua's estimation (we suppose), revenge is not the

correct course of action, and instead, we should seek to forgive our brother. Actually, these verses of our current parashah establish justice in such a situation. For instance, if indeed your brother accidentally (or maliciously) takes your "eye" or "tooth" (these are symbols of your precious commodities), then the ruling says that you are entitled to an equal share of recompense—but not more! This ruling sets the order so that greed and unforgiveness don't become rife in the community. But Yeshua, realizing that the person wronged is owed an "eye" or "tooth" for his compensation, challenges his audience to seek forgiveness instead of compensation. He does NOT contradict the Torah here, rather he establishes it true intent.


 

If the Rabbis are right that money is the compensation, then it can be observed that one who pays compensation for the loss of sight does not make good the damage as one who damages his fellow's goods. The money only serves to make good the monetary damage involved in the loss of the eye or hand, but the actual loss of the eye can never be made good. Injury to another human being is a crime that cannot be made good by ransom or monetary payment. This is the reason why the Torah did not use the expression, "He shall pay for his eye...." This emerges even more clearly from the verse of our parashah that we cited at the beginning of this section. After the punishment for mortally injuring a man or beast is stated (v. 17-18) comes the punishment of the one who causes bodily injury to which the punishment for the one who injures a beast is not juxtaposed. For in the case of man, the difference between mortal injury (murder) and maiming is qualitative (death—money), whereas in the case of beast, there is merely a quantitative difference between killing it and injuring it (greater or lesser compensation according to the injury).

Our parashah concludes by contrasting both: "He who kills an animal is to make restitution, but he who kills another person is to be put to death." (Lev. 24:12) The verse appears superfluous, a repetition of the previous, unless we bear in mind that it wishes to impress upon us the difference between man's responsibility for his fellow's goods and his responsibility for his fellow's life as a human being created in the image of God.


 

Using this as an example to establish "Halachah" for the Torah-based believers in Messiah:

Notice the presentation of this argument presented by "Grafted-In.com:"

  1. First, a passage of Scripture is presented. In this case, Leviticus 24:17-22. In order to be Biblical, there must be a Biblical text underlying any discussion. Otherwise, there is no point to any discussion.
  2. The Mishnah from Talmud is explained. The Mishnah is presented as commentary of this passage of Scripture. The Mishnah was written down beteen 2nd Century BCE until 2nd Century CE. From the Orthodox Jewish perspective, the Mishnah is "oral Torah" and is viewed as equal to Scripture. This is what it means to follow "the Rabbis." A rabbinic approach is a good approach IN REGARDS TO THE CULTURAL CONTEXT. Much of the teachings in Mishnah are believed to predate the first century, even if they were only written down after the 2nd Centery BCE. Thus, for those who believe in Yeshua as the Messiah, this is the strain of thought relevant to the discussions of Yeshua and Rav Shaul (Paul). However, as believers in Messiah, our standard of authority is not the Talmud. This is discussed in #4.
  3. The Gemara on the Mishnah is explained. The Gemara is the second half of Talmud, and it is commentary on the Mishnah. Gemara was written down between 2nd Century CE until 6th Century CE. In other words, the Gemara is a commentary on the commentary of a Scriptural passage. Within the Gemara, explanations from the Rabbis are specifically distinct from the New Testament. By the 2nd Century AD, the Rabbis had to contend with the Messianic Jews of the 1st and 2nd Century. Specific Torah passages were understood in such a way as to show that Yeshua was NOT the Messiah. (We can come to understand this from the context of the book of Galatians. Those who were "bewitching" the Galatian non-Jewish believers in Galatians 3:1 were non-believing Jews. They were not "Judaizers" as is often described. The point is that non-believing Jews during the time of the writing of the New Testament had already begun to work against both Jews and the nations to keep them away from believing in Yeshua.) Thus, for believers in Messiah, one must understand that Gemara is the correct CULTURAL context for reading the New Testament, but the decisions that the non-believing Rabbis had put upon the Jewish culture of their day is not authoritative for Jewish and non-Jewish believers in Yeshua.
  4. A New Testament passage which corresponds to the Torah is explained: The New Testament is contemporary with the early authors of Mishnah, and most of its writings were already in circulation prior to the circulation of the texts of Mishnah. It must be understood that the only proper way to understand the New Testament is as part of Jewish literature, as its authors were all Jewish, and as the subject matter dealt with the Hebrew/Jewish culture of the first century. Thus the reading of Mishnah and the reading of New Testament are co-dependent upon one another in order to understand the meanings of terms used in both books. However, only the New Testament is authoritative upon both the Jewish and non-Jewish believers in Messiah. In reality, only the New Testament is binding upon all of mankind as it is the proper understanding of the Torah. The Messiah, who is the incarnation of Adonai, had come to "properly interpret" Torah (Matthew 5:17-18). The New Testament is where what Yeshua said is written down, thus is carries authoritative weight. Another way of saying this is that the New Testament is the proper "Halachah" for believers in Yeshua Messiah. There is not another book that is needed, only the New Testament.
  5. Note regarding the early Church Fathers: Most of the early Church fathers has begun to swing "the Church" away from Jewish traditions as a whole, and away from the cultural context of the Scriptures. While there are some occasional early Church fathers who were accurate in their explanations of Scripture, there is simply too much European cultural contexts mixed into their explanations that most of them can be set aside as unauthoritative. Writers as early as Clement of Rome (90 CE) can be set aside as due to their syncretizing the message of the Bible with their preferred cultural bias, which tended to be pro-European and anti-semetic. As a result, their writings only lend to misinterpretations, and not proper interpretations of Torah. This is an overgeneralization, but simply said, the Church fathers are not necessary reading material for proper interpretation of Scripture. The Talmud, however, is necessary, yet also unauthoritative.

As can be seen then, the authors of "grafted-in.com" properly assess the way that a believer is to read the Torah. First, Torah passage is read. In this case then, a corresponding New Testament passage is used to properly interpret the meaning of Leviticus 24. The Mishnah and Gemara properly explain that this passage is not to be taken literally. If someone is killed, or someone's property is damaged, monetary compensation is justifiable. The offender and the offendee need to come to terms, and the offender needs to reconcile with the offendee. However, when the interpretation of Yeshua is applied, not only does the offendee need to take responsibility for his actions, but also the offender needs to be forgiving and restore the fellowship. Whereas the Mishnah and Gemara are not incorrect in their interpretation; however, Yeshua's interpretation goes beyond the Rabbis interpretation because both justice and mercy are applied. The offender properly takes account for what he destroyed, and the offendee is held accountable to being forgiving. If both parties properly understand this message of Torah, than there can be true justice, forgiveness can be possible, and healing can begin. And the concept of "eye for eye" will no longer be misunderstood as some sort of injustice, but from now on will be the standard by which universal justice between all men can be achieved. Man will one day have the capacity to truly "love his neighbor as himself."

Sunday, April 18, 2010

The week of April 18-24:

Acharei Mot-Kedoshim - אחרי
מות-קדושים
:
"After the death-Holy"
Torah : Leviticus 16:1-18:30
Haftarah : Ezekiel 22:1-19
Gospel : Luke 14-17

Approaching or Being Removed? Drawing near or Going into Exile? Leviticus 18

Why were the Israelites sent into exile in its historical contexts? In Leviticus 18:3
"You shall not do as they do in the land of Egypt, where you lived, and you shall not do as they do in the land of Canaan, to which I am bringing you. You shall not walk in their statutes." And also in this chapter, Leviticus 18:24-25 "Do not make yourselves unclean by any of these things, for by all these the nations I am driving out before you have become unclean, 25 and the land became unclean, so that I punished its iniquity, and the land vomited out its inhabitants."

The reason that the Canaanites were thrown out of Canaan was due to their violation of these particular commandments. Sexual violations are so depraved that there is no other alternative to fix people other than to utterly destroy them. This was the charge given to Joshua upon taking over the Canaanite land. The phrase, "the land vomited out its inhabitants" is quite a sufficient description of what happens. There are two specific words that are very explanatory as to why this vomiting takes place: Leviticus 18:6 "None of you shall approach any one of his close relatives to uncover nakedness. I am the L-RD." First, the word which means "approach" in Hebrew is KARAV. For those who have studied the sacrifices, they understand that the general word for sacrifices is KARBON, which is the noun form of this verb. "To approach" or "draw near" is used in connection to approaching G-d with acceptable sacrifices, and is also used here to discuss a man approaching a woman in order to have sexual relations. So consider the parallels carefully: The way that we approach G-d by bringing sacrifices is similar to the way a husband draws near to his wife for sexual intimacy. The one action is the ultimate expression of love for G-d, an expression of proper horizontal love relationship with the Creator. The other action is the ultimate expression of human love, the most proper expression of love that the two closest "neighbors" could have with one another. In this type of love for a neighbor, the husband-wife relationship is meant to be sacred and set apart. In the same way, our relationship with G-d is sacred and set apart. By understanding both of these relationships, we now understand more fully the concept of KARAV, "to draw near."

The second word that needs to be understood is the word GALAH, which can be translated as both "uncovered," or "removed." Unlike the English grammatical structure, the Hebrew of Leviticus 18:6 reads more like this, "Man, O man, in the direction of each of flesh of your flesh, DO NOT approach for the purpose of uncovering (or removing) [her] nakedness. I [am] the L-RD." Notice two words in Hebrew for the word "flesh" which is translated as "a close relative." Remember how Paul often talks about "the works of flesh." Paul's use of flesh in his writings is very broad and has many connotations, but very frequently connotes sexual immorality. Notice also that with the "approaching for the purpose of uncovering," the two Hebrew words are side by side. The reason for this is because they are grammatically connected. The "uncovering" serves as the OBJECT of the VERB, "to approach." The bottom line is that one should only have sexual relations with one's wife.

Notice also that the commandments seem to be primarily aimed from the man's perspective. That is not particularly sexist, as modern feminists will argue. It is directed towards men for what should be fairly obvious reasons. In modern world culture, these reasons are not obvious because of different cultures' insensitivities to sexual prohibition. Yet, every day, people see the effects and consequences of these indiscretions, from unwanted pregnancies to abortions and from premarital sex to sexual infidelity to divorce. From a cultural perspective, if the U.S. had left abortion illegal, there would be anywhere between 50 to 200 million more people here in the U.S. Can you think of the economic ramifications of having the additional population with which to come up with new ideas and increase our work sector? We'd have half the population of China, and we'd have a greater need to keep jobs here in the U.S. as opposed to exporting these jobs. Instead of having 50% of dysfunctional families, there would be much greater unity in the UNITED States. But, this is a digression from the Torah.

When we look back at the Lev. 18: 24-25 verses, we also get the connection to why the Canaanites were vomited out of the land. In Genesis 15:16, G-d forwarned Abraham that "the iniquity of the Amorites was not yet filled up." When we apply this basic truth, that sexual immorality, "uncovering nakedness," does eventually lead to exile. This is a grave warning to the cultures of the U.S. The cases of domestic abuse are much higher than most Americans want to admit. "Approximately 15% to 25% of women and 5% to 15% of men were sexually abused when they were children" (Wikipedia). Some websites report a higher number. Homosexuality is not just becoming more common, it is actually being promoted as a more elitist lifestyle, one that has prestige and is specially honored in Hollywood and Washington D.C. There are probably more senators and congressman with homosexual tendencies than is reported. Finally, if you have watched any of the new comedy routines in the last 20 years, the jokes about bestiality are becoming common enough that people actually consider this perversity entertainment. Consider also that the humane society gets more air time than do advertisements promoting a Pro-Life view point. If homosexual marriage becomes legalized, it will only be a matter of time before people will begin to legalize marriages with their pets. Gross, but this is the progression that Torah gives us. The progression of the downfall goes from having adultery, to sexually abusing family members, to homosexuality to bestiality. At that point, the land vomits the people out. Consider also these statistics amongst those who say they are believers: The population who call themselves evangelical Christian have a divorce rate that is roughly at or above 50%. For evangelical pastors, the divorce rate is at about 65%, more or less. Add on top of this, with the scandalous homosexual and pedophile accusations against Catholic priests, it can be clearly understood that the sexual immorality of people who call themselves "Christians" has also reached vomit capacity. It is only a matter of time. It is no wonder that people overall reject the notion of going to church. It's not G-d that they hate; it is that the lifestyles of believers do not match what is commanded in the Bible.

The solution to this is very clear: STOP! REPENT! Whatever your sexual immoral behavior is, it must be stopped! One must FIGHT the urges of the flesh. The battle against our flesh is no longer an internal struggle. It is now a national epidemic, and for every immoral act we commit or tolerate as believers puts us one step closer to the day the land vomits us out. To stop the advance of this immorality we must begin somewhere. The place to begin is a renewed commitment amongst all those from a Bible based belief system to agree to keep the commandments that G-d has given. One place to start is with the Shabbat, the Sabbath. We must renew our commitment to keep it. But not just to keep it at all, but also to guard it. And then, we need to keep/guard it as holy, set apart. We need to stop working on Sabbath. We need to stop buying and selling on Sabbath. We need to honor people. We need to stop taking His name in vain. AND, we must stop committing adultery and all forms of immorality as described here in Leviticus. If we are going to be actively promoting a Torah-based lifestyle, it must begin with us keeping His commandments—not just talking about them, but DOING them.

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Cleansing

Leviticus 14:2 "This shall be the law of the leprous person for the day of his cleansing. He shall be brought to the priest…

Leviticus 14:20 And the priest shall offer the burnt offering and the grain offering on the altar. Thus the priest shall make atonement for him, and he shall be clean.


 

Let us begin this double portion with discussing one of the main topics that seems to be woven throughout this passage: the concept of "cleansing." The meaning of this term is out-of-context for the native English speaker. We really have nothing in American or Western culture with which to connect the concept of "being clean" as it pertains to this section of Torah. In other words, we will have to accept the terms as they are without trying to relate it to our own experiences.

First, let us dispel the common English connotations of the meaning of "clean" and "cleanse."

  1. I took a shower today; therefore I am "clean."
  2. The doctor had to "cleanse" the wound before he could begin surgery."
  3. Did you "clean" the dishes?
  4. Jesus died so that He might "cleanse" us from our sins.

In the first sentence, "clean" is an adjective, and it describes the state of a person after having applied soap and water. The meaning is clear to us. The second example is a verb, and it implies a more medical connotation. The doctor must decrease the medical contaminants in order to reduce the risk of infection during a surgical procedure. The application here is quite literal. In the third sentence, we have the word "clean" in another verb usage. Here, the action of cleaning can be applied to objects, not just people or animals. Finally, the term "cleanse" here applies to a theological discussion which is common in Christian thinking. While it may sound like a nice thing to say, it may not be accurate according to the Torah usage.

The Hebrew term for "cleansing" is "Tahair." A term for a leper is "M'tzorah." A leper is the worst type of uncleanness that a person could experience. The question that one must ask is what is the purpose of the "cleansing" as discussed in the Torah?

Now, at the basic level of understanding, most people associate uncleanness with specific sins. For example, in traditional rabbinic literature, the "metzorah" is often connected to the concept of "lashon hara." I very recently read that the word "rah," the word for evil, is in both of these words: meztoRAH and lashon HARA. Lashon hara literally means "evil speaking." The rabbinic idea is that if a person is guilty of speaking evil against someone else, than one of the consequences might be the development of leprosy. One common story is found in Numbers 12:10 when Miriam becomes leprous for having spoken against Moses. As a result, the connection of "evil speaking" and "leprosy" are often linked within Judaism. During this time of year, it is certainly reasonable for each of us to reflect on whether or not we speak evil against others. If so, it certainly is a good time of year for us to repent of using evil words against others, whether to their face or behind their back, we should enter into repentance.

However, the more literal connection of the terms leper and cleansing has to with a connection to death. Leprosy was such a terrible disease that those who were lepers had to live in a separate colony or somewhere outside the camp, as was described by Torah. Now, some say that the leprosy of that era could not be medically described by our standards today. The descriptions of leprosy as discussed in Torah do not fit the descriptions of what doctors call leprosy today. They most likely are not the same disease at all. The leprosy of Torah implies that the leper, the metzorah, as regarded as "the walking dead." Thus, being cleansed from leprosy, thus carried the connotation of having returned from death, or being resurrected.

Leviticus 14 outlines what the leper was to do in order to become clean. The leper was to bring two turtledoves (live clean birds) on the first day, and then three different lambs in order to be sacrificed for the eighth day. Also, cedar wood, hyssop, and a scarlet thread are brought with the living bird. One of the living birds is sacrificed, and then the living bird is dipped in the blood of the first one, along with the three other elements. Rashi says that this twittering bird was to remind the metzorah that it was his or her chattering that caused the leprosy in the first place, so this is why a bird was chosen. However, this really doesn't get at the heart of the matter regarding the process for which the living dead person is going to be brought back to life. There is something to the idea that death of the one bird brings about the freedom for the other bird. As to the cedar wood, the hyssop, and the red string, there is a significance which can be discussed at a later time, along with the concept of the red heifer. These three things were used during this ceremony as well.

Once the leper has performed these actions outside the camp, then the leper shaves, and then is allowed to come back into the camp, but only to stay for a week outside of his tent. He is to bathe and to shave off all of his hair. Now, there is certainly the idea of being clean which includes the simple concept of the state of not being physically dirty. The application for this ceremony must be seen as both practical, but also spiritual.

On the eighth day, the man is allowed to bring three offerings up to the tabernacle: First, two male lambs and one female lamb is brought. Consider the implications from the meaning of these three lambs. The first lamb is a male, and it is brought as a guilt-offering. Remember, the guilt offering is not a sin offering, it is an offering brought for the sake of one's conscience. We often must deal with the guilt of a sin prior to dealing with the sin itself. The blood of this lamb and a mixture of oil is put onto the right ear, the right thumb, and the right big toe of the former metzorah. Just as Moses did this at the initiation of Aaron into priesthood, so too is this done, to initiate the person back into life. The second offering is the sin offering, which provides the atonement. Finally, the last lamb is brought as a free-will/elevation offering, in order to reestablish that lost fellowship in drawing near to G-d. At this point, the leper has now been cleansed.

Here is the important concept that one must add to the concept of "clean." It is not that outward appearance that makes one clean. (However, if one does not have any hygiene, it would be interesting to describe this person's relationship with G-d.) There is a certain truth to cleanliness is next to godliness. But what is important to note is that in order to approach G-d, we must be clean within our lives. In order to draw near to G-d, we need to let go of certain kinds of things that are related to death within our lives. What is it that causes you to live as a "walking-dead" within your work week? Does your job depress you? Either get a new job, or find out why it is that G-d has placed you in that workplace. Are there difficulties within your family? If you are not clean, you are going to have a difficult time approaching G-d to deal with the problem. We all carry around things and ideas that lead to death, or we have been touched by those around us who have in turn touched death. The concept of clean and unclean does not apply in the American context. But if we know that we are in a bad place in our lives, why not consider the offerings brought by the leper: Make an offering to deal with your guilt, your conscience. Then, our trust in Yeshua as the ultimate sin offering should bring about within us an attitude of humility and gratitude for what He accomplished for our personal lives. We should thank Him regularly. And if you are reading this, and you have never accepted Yeshua as the Messiah of Israel, nor have you allowed Him to be the L-rd of your life, then there is no better time to receive the sacrifice made by Yeshua. Just pray and ask Him to forgive you of your sin. And then, the final offering can be brought: the free will offering, where the once leprous person has been fully restored to the people of G-d, and the leper can draw near to G-d and be in fellowship with Him.

We may not all exhibit the outward signs of leprosy, but we know that inside, we go through times where we feel like the walking dead. So, during this particular time, you can be invited to bring your offerings to G-d--read to Torah, sing praises to Him, pray—and renew your relationship with the G-d of the Universe! Let the L-rd cleanse you, and be clean!

Thursday, April 8, 2010

“On the eighth day”

What was it that Aaron did on the eighth day? I will discuss this in one moment, but first one must also ask, "When is the eighth day?"
If there are only seven days in a week, how does one have an "eighth" day? The rabbis have always described an eighth day as a day outside of time. There are different things that are done on eighth days, such as the eighth day after Passover is an extra day of rest, as is the eighth day of Sukkot. Also, the day that babies are brought to the Temple for circumcision is on the eighth day. This day represents a father and mother's commitment to the covenant of Israel, an eternal covenant. By performing this mitzvah, the family is making a connection to eternity. They are also agreeing to live in the present by actually performing this action.

Aaron has a specific duty that was commanded of him in order to bring about the "glory of the L-rd." This occasion could only be done once, as it was the inauguration of the Temple services. It was his and everyone else's first time. Glory means something like weightiness, honor, rich in appearance or abundance in possessions. Exactly what the people were to experience is contained in this word, but to understand this word, one must experience this. Quickly, here is the order and the sacrifices that Aaron brought:

Sacrifice

Animal/Grain

Purpose

  1. Sin offering

Young bull

By bringing this sin offering, Aaron is first seeing that his sin has been covered over. (See Lev. 4) The value of a young bull is perhaps the most valuable animal in Israel. One young bull could recreate many more animals in its lifetime. Thus this sacrifice was valuable. For Aaron, unless he has dealt with his own sin, how can he bring the rest of Israel's offerings?

  1. Whole Burnt Offering

Young ram

(See Lev. 1) An whole burnt offering allows Aaron to "draw near" to the L-rd. This is its name—the "Olah.) A ram is also an expensive offering, but more than a bull? What can be added is that two shofars could be taken from the head of a ram. This signifies the sacrifice that Isaac was willing to make. There is a connection to these consistent renewals of the covenant.

  1. Another sin offering

Male Goat

This sin offering parallels the above sin offering, but this one is brought on behalf of all of corporate Israel. It has the same purpose, except that the value of the goat would have been less. Notice, though, these are all male sacrifices.

  1. Another whole burnt offering

A lamb and a calf

This whole burnt offering is brought on behalf of corporate Israel. It allows all of Israel to draw near to the L-rd. Again, these are less expensive animals. One thought: the lamb is only mentioned in the context of ALL of Israel, not just Aaron.

  1. Grain offering mixed with oil

Unleavened bread

This sacrifice reminds us of the fruit of the ground that is provided for Israel. It is unleavened to remind us that we must remain before the L-rd without our sin. We must work to continue to remain sinless. Obviously, the L-rd knows of the futility of man being without sin; however, it is the responsibility of man to continually take up the contention against sin in one's life and within Israel, and stop the sinning.


 

All of these sacrifices taken individually for Aaron, and corporately for Israel are an "avodah" to the L-rd, or an "act of service." By doing this, the L-rd is pleased, and His glory can stay with Israel. When His glory arrives, Moses and Aaron then go into the tent of meeting with the L-rd. When they come out, the two of them bless Israel. When they receive the blessing, the glory goes out, which then lets the people know that the glory has arrived, because they all fall down in His presence (Lev. 9:24).

Do we really want significant change in our lives? Are we really willing to take a stand against the sin in our life, and the lives of others to bring about G-d's glory? Consider this parallel to our lives:

When we need to approach G-d, we need to approach him with a valuable sin offering—in this case, our lives. We need to repent of our sin, and we need to approach Him with our drawing near to Him (our burnt offering.) Next, we need to offer of sacrifices of prayer for those in our lives that G-d has allowed us to be in contact with. In this case, we serve in the role of priest for others, bringing their lives before Him. Only one sacrifice will suffice—the blood of the goat, and then the blood of the Lamb. Finally, we must continually work out the sin (leaven) in our lives, as well as stand in for others, helping them to rid sin out of their lives. If we will take seriously our responsibilities, both for ourselves and for those around us, we will see the glory of the L-rd. When will we know that He has arrived in this way? We will know when we as a community are face down before His glory.

This is not an act of "waiting for the Messiah." This is an act we can start any day. We all need to have a dedication of our temples to G-d, even if it is a rededication.

Shabbat Shalom!

Sunday, April 4, 2010

Ezekiel 37:1-14 and the Valley of Dry Bones

For those of you who have read last week's haftarah portion, here is an opportunity for us to have an interesting discussion. I hope many of you who read this will take an opportunity to type in your reaction to the following question:

Has the prophecy from Ezekiel about the dry bones in the middle of the valley a past tense occurrence, a present tense occurrence, or something that we are still waiting to see?

First, it is important to read the text given above. The basic passage is the L-RD told Ezekiel to prophecy to these bones, to hear the word of the L-RD, and to live again. They need to have breath given to them again. The L-RD explains the prophecy to mean that Israel would return from having been dead, and that they would be placed in their own land.

Here are a list of questions to work through:

  1. Read alsol Ezekiel 36:22-38 and 37:15-28. How do these passages explain about Israelites being placed in their land?
  2. Are the bones real, or are they figurative to something else?
  3. What or Who is the "hand of the L-RD"? 37:1
  4. What does it mean to "prophesy"? Obviously, prophesying to some dry bones does not imply some sort of future forecasting. Prophesying must means something else, not about the future.
  5. Is the Son of Man (Ben HaAdam) a reference to a man or to Someone more than a man?
  6. What is the "breath"?
  7. Does Israel receive the land once they receive the breath, or before?
  8. Are there any allusions to resurrection in this passage?
  9. In 37:24, who is the servant David?
  10. In the reunion of Ephraim and Judah, is this a past occurrence or a future one?
    1. When Yeshua was in Israel, where did He do His ministry? Look at a map in your Bible and take note of ALL of the places Yeshua visited.
    2. Look at a map that shows where Galilee is, and where the tribe of Ephraim would have been during the books of the Kings and Chronicles. Do you see the intersection?
  11. Read Jeremiah 7:32-8:1. Why did G-d allow there to be bodies thrown into this valley? What did the Israelites do that caused G-d to allow this disaster to happen?

Check back later this week for some other discussions will be posted to continue this discussion. Please, feel free to post some of your discussions!